GRANTHAM AND STANASOLOVICH DISCUSS MARKET
VALUATIONS
Jeremy Grantham of Grantham, Mayo, Van Otterloo and Co., LLC and a
legend in the investment industry with over forty years experience,
discussed his views on investing recently with Lou Stanasolovich, CFP™,
CEO and President of Legend Financial Advisors, Inc. (Legend). Many
regard Jeremy in the same light as investment veterans Warren Buffet,
Bill Gross, Steven Leuthold, Robert Arnott, and Cliff Asness.
Grantham discussed his valuation models of numerous asset classes
and how they historically relate to the financial markets currently.
His financial data is rivaled only by that of Steven Leuthold with
regard to historical comprehensiveness. A review of the data revealed
that large U.S. stocks (S&P500) are still grossly overvalued.
Investors optimistically should expect no more than a 2.9% compound
return for the S&P 500 over the next seven (7) years before
inflation and income taxes. Other asset classes such as domestic
small cap stocks should double the performance of large S&P 500
stocks turning in a 5.9% compound return. Although not a great
return, it is superior in comparison to the alternative. The
valuation models also revealed that U.S. bonds should provide a
moderately higher return than the S&P 500. Asset classes that
should do well because of their low market valuations include; REITs,
hedge-type investments, small and large international stocks
particularly those with a value orientation, emerging market bonds
and emerging market equities, as well as commodities. Returns from
these types of investments should provide returns of 8% to 12% due to
their low valuations over the same seven (7)-year period.
Historically, when price-to-earnings ratios (P/E = prices of
stocks divided by their earnings – a common measure of value) have
been in the top 20% of valuations as they currently are (actually
despite three years of a falling stock market, current valuations are
the third highest of all time), the average return for a ten
(10)-year period when the market is as highly valued as it is, has
been 0.2% above inflation- (currently projected at 2.2%). That’s
correct, 0.2%. Grantham believes that current valuations on the
S&P 500 causes even this minuscule return projection to be
optimistic.
While discussing "bubble markets" (this includes stock
markets around the world, currencies, commodities), such as the
current one, Grantham cited that such market periods have always
resulted in devastating losses for investors. In fact, since 1900,
not including the current bubble, in 27 out of 27
"bubbles," losses exceeded 100% of the gains previously
earned. Furthermore, valuations based upon ten (10)-year normalized
(earnings are averaged over years) P/E levels dropped not only below
historical median valuations, they went far below the median. This
would imply a Dow Jones Industrial Average to be near a 4,000 level
(see Bill Gross’ article entitled, "Dow 5,000" in
September of 2002 at http://www.pimco.com).
You may also recall that in 1996, when the stock market was
skyrocketing and had reached the 6,000 level, present Federal Reserve
Chairman, Alan Greenspan stated this was due to irrational
exuberance. Please keep in mind that we are discussing the valuations
of one asset class, U.S. large stocks, and not all asset classes. As
a result of these unarguable facts, we believe we have positioned our
portfolios to take advantage of these trends and to avoid the
inevitable.
For Further information on Market Valuations contact Louis
P. Stanasolovich, CFPä , CEO and
President at (412) 635-9210 Extension 21.
Legend Financial Advisors, Inc.
5700 Corporate Drive, Suite 350
Pittsburgh, PA 15237-5829
Phone: (412) 635-9210
Fax: (412) 635-9213
Toll Free: (888) 236-5960
E-mail: legend@legend-financial.com
Web Site: www.legend-financial.com